Insights / Articles

Personalising EX: Alternatives to the Carrot and Stick Approach

Personalising EX: Alternatives to the Carrot and Stick Approach

For many years, the carrot and stick approach has been the go-to method for motivating employees in the workplace.

The idea behind this approach is simple: offer incentives (the carrot) for good behaviour and punish (the stick) those who fail to meet expectations. However, recent studies have shown that this approach is becoming less effective and may even have a negative impact on employee performance and job satisfaction.

Why is the carrot and stick approach no longer effective and what alternative methods can employers use to motivate their employees?

We are not all the same

First and foremost, the carrot and stick approach assumes that all employees are motivated by the same things, namely rewards and punishments. However, research has shown that this is not always the case. While some employees may be motivated by financial incentives, (and the number for whom material rewards are the most important motivating factor is lower than you might think), ­others may be more motivated by peer recognition or the opportunity to take on more challenging tasks. By relying solely on the carrot and stick approach, employers are missing out on what motivates their employees individually and almost certainly won’t be getting the best out of them as a result.

A culture of fear

Secondly, the carrot and stick approach can create a culture of fear and resentment in the workplace. When employees are constantly being watched and evaluated based on their performance, they may feel like they are under constant pressure to perform, which can lead to stress and anxiety. Furthermore, if employees feel like they are being punished unfairly, they may start to resent their employer and may become less motivated to do their best work.

Capture not puncture creativity

Finally, the carrot and stick approach does not encourage creativity or innovation in the workplace. When employees are focused solely on meeting specific targets or goals, they may be less likely to take risks or try new things. The World Economic Forum expects creativity to rank third as the most important work skill by 2025, so stifling it is an excellent way of shooting yourself in the foot.

Cultivate and create a positive culture

So, what can employers do instead of relying on the carrot and stick approach to motivate their employees? One alternative is to focus on creating a positive work culture that emphasises collaboration, open communication, and employee engagement. By creating a work environment that is supportive and empowering, employers can help to foster a sense of ownership and commitment among their employees, which can lead to higher levels of job satisfaction and better performance.

Another effective approach is to provide employees with opportunities for growth and development. This can involve offering training programs, mentoring, or other forms of professional development that allow employees to enhance their skills and advance their careers within the organisation. By investing in the growth and development of their employees, employers can help to create a workforce that is motivated, engaged, and committed to the success of the organisation.

Mojo is a cloud-based platform that uses ISO-accredited Motivational Maps to identify and satisfy what is needed at an individual, team and organisational level to develop and maintain a happy and productive workforce. With a focus on nine different motivators, mojo identifies which of the nine motivators are most important to individual employees and your organisation as a whole, at any time. Because motivation is fluid, mojo provides ongoing insight and mojo's reward strategies to optimise the motivation and performance of their teams.

In conclusion, while the carrot and stick approach may have worked in the past, it is becoming less effective in today's workplace. By focusing on what motivates their employees as individuals, employers can personalise the employee experience and create a positive, high performance work culture that is truly engaged, committed, and ready to take on new challenges.

Every employee has the potential to be a top performer. If you're looking to boost employee engagement, productivity, and performance, then mojo can help. Contact us today for a complimentary consultation and personalised mojo demo.